Wednesday, April 3, 2013

PAX, GDC, IGF, RIP: A Meandering, Fatigued Look At The Last Two Weeks


Having been to PAX East this year, not even a week later most of the memories are hazy stretches of nothing. After paying the yearly tithe to the overlords of video game culture, I planned in between seeing a few friends and acquaintances on and off the floor to get my rare glimpse of into the beating heart of darkness of culture, just like the last two years. Ticket fees were rationalized away as being a chance to get material for reporting, fuel for griping and critiquing and lambasting and lampooning.

If the title lumping in a bunch of other stuff was any indication, nothing really came up. Maybe it wasn't the right panels, maybe it wasn't the right booths, maybe it was missing all the right podcasts and people and presentations and parties, but on this trip into what's supposed be one of the public epicenters of nerd culture, there was just… emptiness. More than one event was shrugged off just to keep sitting in quiet corridors, charging a phone and reading a book. I had plenty of memorable experiences thanks to Greater Boston Area being a wonderful place, like the Thursday night farewell to regular weekly content for the Rock Band series in Cambridge or a peaceful steakhouse dinner with an extended circle of Internet acquaintances, but the memories that rang the most true were almost universally outside of the expo hall.

Alt text: "Goodbye to over 5 years of my life. This'll be the day that I die."

Obviously there were welcome exceptions to the malaise. I had a great time absorbing Hot Journalism Tips from industry bigwigs (hashtag WhyGameJourno) and dizzily shaking my head at Utilikilts and Vibrams toe shoes. As far as sincere enjoyment, the smaller PC developers and bigger-ticket indies maintained their usual charming enthusiasm. I learned after the first year that any booth with a line wrapping around it is a waste compared to games with actual onlooking crowds or open stations, so I had next to no wait getting my hands on Dropchord (intriguing), Octodad: Dadliest Catch (as fun as the original prototype), and Soda Drinker Pro (the most revolutionary title on the show floor).  I saw a lot of faces again, some for the first time, and even accidentally picked up a business card or two, and those were the moments that meant something to me. All totaled, though, they were kind of sparse.

Where a different Adam managed to spin his experiences into three separate articles, I can't even finish one. The console releases which flooded the expo floor were mostly speculative puffs of titles on barely-announced future consoles or the last dying embers of the current one, years-long game series taking victory laps or their last bows. There was next to nothing revealed or explored, nearly nothing to show for the whole event except a sense of almost begrudging ceremony. (The tabletop section was its usual, serene, composed, better-smelling self that I don't presume enough about to honestly reflect.) Everything from the dwindling cosplayer count to the Bioware self-love shrine to the misogynist offenses seems felt completely perfunctory.

Alt text: "Now last year's outrage-driving controversy at least had some panache to it."

At GDC and IGF, on the other hand, stuff totally went down. Even the horrific sexism went down with more sincere gusto! Clearly the West Coast still has that action wrapped up tight compared to crabby old-school Atlantic types. Finally, the indie kids get to shoot themselves in the foot just like the big boys, right down to the paternalistic protection instinct and shaming of the hired guests. Looks like when you resign yourself to rebuilding all existing feminist theory from square one you can't start skipping waves or borrowing any lessons already learned from history. nerd culture, everybody.

Richard Hofmeier's response to winning the Seumas McNally Prize at IGF with Cart Life was also telling. Here was the creator of one of the most poignant manifestations to date of a mechanically robust game using its systems to emphasize its message and story… and he felt so utterly displaced and unworthy that he wished his game death and forfeited his booth to a graffitied takeover by interactive fiction writer Porpentine and her work howling dogs. Noble, certainly, but it adds on to the disheartening resistance to embracing gameplay as the driving force of games that plagues as many independent developers as it does the AAA industry it claims to repudiate. The former keeps growing to mirror the latter more and more every day, and one of the people who might buck this trend feels utterly unworthy in the community that should continue to sing his praises and look to creators like him for the way forward.

Alt text: "Fearing that Mr. Glembovski was lost was more real and immediate than anything I ever felt about Braid, and that's some Real Talk."

Lulls happen, and there's no way around it. Some years boom and others bust, but a stirring muse it doesn't make. For all the complaints about the extended generation of home consoles, you can see the strain on a lot of peoples' faces to get back on the hype train for new DRM-laden boxes that are liable to set their up-to-date libraries back to zero again. The PC folks get to skip this whole affair, but the upheaval going on is too vast and dramatic to really get a solid read on the future. Maybe it's not the poetic answer or the one that gives over best to a coherent narrative (or article) but it's what there is. There's the sense of something ending without being sure how to feel about what's about to begin, ennui mixed with confusion and change, but it's a healthy uncertainty and uneasiness given the times. Growing pains.

At least we can all keep laughing at Sim City in the meantime. Haha! What a mess.

Saturday, February 16, 2013

With Friends Like These [Nice(r) Version]


Randy Pitchford is a happy man. Sure, the last couple of major titles he's overseen as head of Gearbox Software have had their share of detractors, but that's not going to be any skin off of his nose. If someone eventually suffers in the wake of our collective gangland beatdown of the shoddy stillborn mess that was Aliens: Colonial Marines, it's not going to be him. It'll be someone who we as an industry have decided is more expendable. Maybe it's going to be whoever textured the sliding space doors, or maybe the employee who coded the pathfinding AI on the xenomorphs, or maybe even whoever was responsible for the flaccid, revisionist narrative. Maybe the seemingly bogus finger-pointing at TimeGate Studios will cast enough doubt and they'll absorb all the damage instead. Whoever gets the blame, their releases from the company will most likely transpire without a sound. They'll be out on the street, while somewhere in Dallas will be Randy Pitchford, unfazed. It's good to be Randy. Randy is untouchable.

It doesn't matter whether his studio releases an open target for near-universal critical panning, a competent multiplayer shooter almost suffocated by Family Guy levels of un-humor and questionable "aesthetic borrowing" practices, or dressing up the beaten carcass of a crass 90s FPS in extra layers of puerile filth. Pitchford is the one at the studio's helm, and until the whole operation goes under, he'll be right there, and the people he hires will by and large be sympathetic to his guiding vision. He'll always have a couple of reliable fans who'll pony up their $60 cut, and enough warmly-remembered handshakes with the press in his back pocket to weather any storm. He came through the release of Duke Nukem Forever without a scratch, and that was a jittering, broken mess that also came jam-packed with horrific misogyny and racism, both in the game and in its promotional tactics. What could a paper cut like Marines possibly do to someone who's quickly becoming known best for running his mouth and shooting himself in the foot?

Alt-text: "Should've done something here with more memes; more Reddit-friendly. Their input is PRICELESS to me."

Not everyone is afforded the Pitchford protection plan, of course. If the team at Mollieindustria tries to sell Phone Story on the App Store, they'll get pulled. If David Gallant makes I Get This Call Every Day and the Toronto Star outs him as the designer, he's out the door and can only hope his game sales keep him and his family afloat. If Everyone's Twitter Buddy Mike Sacco so much as suggests that Pitchford and his flunkies might be unfunny hack writers at best and racially insensitive at worst, Kotaku goes and fires up their gossip engine, setting events in motion that force Sacco to either be silenced or leave his job. Gawker Media's redheaded stepchild will even get a second headline out of the exchange for their troubles! We can be as justly incensed at all these outcomes as much as we want, but ultimately there will be many of us who are still going to perpetuate the kind of industrial climate that made those things happen. Guess it didn't bother us that much, then, did it?

Those who claim the mantle of journalism and reporting aren't exactly a collection of saints, either. You can talk as much game about social progressivism as you want, but at the end of the day, when you answer to the guidelines vetted by Stephen Totilo, you've put your paycheck in front of your idealism and the size of your audience in front of its quality. You're also faced with well-seasoned glad-handers like Ben Kuchera, who can do things like refuse to condemn a game like RapeLay without "first-hand knowledge", openly wish ill on another writer's career the second he sees the word "emulator", and make a habit of smug dismissal to anyone with the backbone to call him out on his behavior. (Points still due to the man for "broken clock" moments, like bashing targets as easy as DNF, of course.) But that was then, and this is the now when Kuchera is writing for Mike Krahulik, one of the reigning champions of Dumb Internet Drama for Man-Children.

Alt-text: "And yet I'm still going to Boston in March. Yes, I am an idiot. Please berate me."

But here's the thing: he's the man-child with the money. Video games, despite all the incessant straining for validation via being "art" now (and at no prior point in their history) through tortured academic analysis, are a multi-billion-dollar capitalist industry. If he is one of the men who have a decade under his belt of accruing a fan base and a war chest, then he gets to speak loudest. You can compound that with being a gatekeeper for the premier industry charity, where the people who play and make and cover games all pay their Catholic-style moral indulgences as if by default. You can compound that with running several of the premier fan conventions / press junkets for that same industry. What you get is an indelible mark on the rickety excuse for a "gamer culture" that follows in his less-than-stellar image, and enough clout to overcome and marginalize PR damage in any situation ranging from rape victim harassment to promoting similarly questionable card games to self-subsidizing through the wallets of your fans and beyond. There's much to laud about the industry-wide unity that admirably gets people running to the aid of those displaced by layoffs and closures, make no mistake. But that same atmosphere becomes insularity when it keeps around its toxic relics indefinitely, and broken when strikes down anyone like Sacco who might see something in need of repair.

Money is the most obvious conduit of power, and power in society is not entropic: it pools and aggregates with people who already have it and can exert it, who can maintain it and accrue more. It's what makes corporate-friendly mouthpieces like Kuchera froth at the mouth the second he misinterprets Kain as so much as excusing a single instance of quasi-piracy. It's also why, from the side of users and consumers, issues like backwards compatibility and always-online DRM and preventative measures against the used game market are perpetual sources of contentious rumors for next-generation consoles. It even gets to the root of why the medium lags so pitifully behind on tackling issues of race and gender or any kind of social justice: the financial barrier for entry on both creators and audiences is drastically higher than literature or film or theater or painting or sculpture or any other format on the other side of arts funding. That baked-in privilege (multiplied by the long-standing historical biases in STEM-intensive studies and pastimes) is a stumbling block we are perpetually clawing our way over, and why we're forced to replay every wave of every modern civil rights movement back from square one as the rest of society clucks its tongues at us. We've only just started winding down after the latest act in a 20-year parade of playing political scapegoat for greater societal issues. And after all this time, statements like Simon Parkin's brilliant Eurogamer piece on games with licensed guns are exceedingly rare in their willingness to raise questions and accept at least some responsibility. The rest of the time is spent wading through entrenchments of snide dismissal, defensive posturing, and embarrassing babbling about the First Amendment in the service of a collective victim complex.

Alt-text: "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ChX4C56kITc"

Trying to resist complicity in that money trail is where the entire concept of the "independent scene" comes from, and why it's so important as a production ethic. It involves operating at a smaller scale and trying to mitigate at least some of that participation bias. Phone Story used its medium and design ethos to bolster its message about the horrible prices others pay for our luxuries: four mini-games in a looped "Obsolescence Mode" with each cycle representing a new model of the phone you're probably playing the game on. Sure, the "indie game" scene in conjunction with "New Games Journalism" generates plenty of auteur worship and faux-academic navel-gazing. It's aggravating when relatively smart people fail to realize both "input without player agency" and "Slavoj Žižek analyses without self-awareness" are usually just Really Tedious Exercises, and you can get anxious all that passion and creativity is going to go to wasted on some pithy salon culture. Even so, underneath all that preening and posturing, there is ultimately a kernel of truth with a far more valid claim at the populist spirit than the AAA system could or would ever offer.

There's nothing that confirms this way of analyzing the world than the framing we use to predict the future of the current studio system in our worries over another "collapse". But just because Call of Duty has to start receding sometime doesn't mean anyone's can scry the coming of the next epoch from sales figures alone. Despite Gearbox's colossal efforts, the landscape is too diverse for any single game to cause an Atari E.T.-level fiasco that cripples the whole industry. For big-ticket developers, the talent pool changes every time new crops of fresh-out-of-school undergraduates from college "game design curricula" hit the job market. (And having an industry perpetually overfilled with workers sure hurts efforts to make unionization seem realistic, doesn't it?) You'll never be able to simply wish away the smudges and stains that Pitchford and Kuchera and Krahulik and Kotaku and turbulent employment practices have left on us all. The only threat to the status quo comes when you start working with models and ideas that would make them obsolete. If they start treating you like a threat, then you might just be onto something.

Thursday, February 14, 2013

With Friends Like These

Randy Pitchford is a happy man. Sure, the last couple of major titles he's overseen as head of Gearbox Software have had their share of detractors, but that's not going to be any skin off of his nose. If someone eventually suffers in the wake of our collective gangland beatdown of the shoddy stillborn mess that was Aliens: Colonial Marines, it's not going to be him. It'll be someone who we as an industry have decided is more expendable. Maybe it's going to be whoever textured the explosive containers, or maybe the employee who coded the pathing AI on the xenomorphs, or maybe even whoever was responsible for the hack-job on the narrative. Maybe the seemingly bogus finger-pointing at TimeGate studios will pay its dividends and they'll absorb all the damage instead. Whoever gets the blame, their releases from the company will transpire without a sound; they'll be out on the street, and somewhere in Dallas will be Randy Pitchford, unfazed. Because it's good to be Randy; Randy is untouchable.

It doesn't matter whether his studio releases an open target for near-universal critical panning, a competent multiplayer suffocating in Family Guy levels of un-humor, or dressing up the beaten carcass of a 90s FPS in extra layers of puerile filth. Pitchford is the one at the studio's helm, and until the whole operation goes under, he'll be right there, and the people he hires will by and large be sympathetic to his "vision". He'll always have a couple of reliable fanboys who'll pony up their $60 cut, and enough warm handshakes with the press in his back pocket to weather any storm. He came through the release of Duke Nukem Forever without a scratch, and that was a jittering, broken mess that also came jam-packed with horrific misogyny (and racism!) both in the game and in its promotional tactics. What could a paper cut like Marines possibly do to someone who's quickly becoming known best for running his mouth and shooting himself in the foot?

Alt-text: "Should've done something with more memes; more Reddit-friendly. Their input is PRICELESS to me."

Not everyone has can Pitchford protection plan, of course. If the team at Mollieindustria tries to sell Phone Story on the App Store, they get pulled. If David Gallant makes I Get This Call Every Day and the Toronto Star outs him as the designer, he's out the door and can only hope his game sales keep him and his family afloat. If Mike Sacco so much as suggests that Pitchford and his flunkies might be unfunny hack writers at best and racially insensitive at worst, Kotaku goes and fires up their gossip engine, setting events in motion that force Sacco to either resign himself to silence or quit his job. Gawker Media's redheaded stepchild will even get a second headline out of the exchange for their troubles! We can be as justly incensed at all these outcomes as much as we want, but ultimately there will be many of us who are still going to perpetuate the kind of industrial climate that made those things happen. Guess it didn't bother us that much, then, did it?

Those who claim the mantle of journalism and reporting aren't exactly a collection of saints, either. You can talk as much game about social progressivism as you want, but, at the end of the day, when you answer to the guidelines vetted by Stephen Totilo, you've put your paycheck in front of your idealism and the quantity of your audience in front of its quality. You're also faced with ancient bottom-feeders like Ben Kuchera, who do things like refuse to condemn a game like RapeLay without "first-hand knowledge", openly wish ill on another writer's career the second he sees the word "emulator", and make a habit of smug dismissal to anyone who calls you out on it. (Points still due for "broken clock" moments like bashing an easy target like DNF, of course.) But that was then, and this is the now when you're writing for one of the reigning champions of Dumb Internet Drama for Man-Children.

Alt-text: "And yet I'm still going to Boston in March. Yes, I am an idiot, please berate me."

But here's the thing: they're the man-children with the money. Video games, despite all the incessant straining for validation via being "art" now (and at no prior point in their history) through tortured academic analysis, are a multi-billion-dollar capitalist industry. If those are the people who have a decade under their belts of accruing a fan base and a war chest, then they get to speak loudest. You can compound that with being the gatekeepers of the premier industry charity, where the people who play and make and cover games all default to for their Catholic-style moral indulgences. You can compound that with running several of the premier fan conventions / press junkets for that same industry. What you get is an indelible mark and a rickety excuse for a "culture" that follows in their less-than-stellar image, with the size to overcome and marginalize PR damage in any situation from rape victim harassment to promoting similarly questionable card games to self-subsidizing through the wallets of your fans. There's much to laud about the industry-wide unity that admirably gets people to run to the aid of those displaced by layoffs and closures, make no mistake. But that same atmosphere becomes insularity when it keeps around toxic relics like Pitchford indefinitely and strikes down anyone like Sacco who might see something in real need of repair.

Money is the most obvious conduit of power, and power in society is not entropic: it pools and aggregates with people who already have it and can exert it. It's what makes corporate-friendly mouthpieces like Kuchera froth at the mouth the second he misinterprets Kain as so much as excusing a single instance of quasi-piracy. It's also why, from the side of users and consumers, issues like backwards compatibility and always-online DRM and preventative measures against the used game market are perpetual sources of contentious rumors for next-generation consoles. It even gets to the root of why the medium lags so pitifully behind on tackling issues of race and gender; the financial barrier for entry on both creators and audiences is drastically higher than literature or film or theater or painting or sculpture or any other format on the other side of arts funding. That (along with the long-standing historical bias against women participating in STEM-intensive studies and pastimes) is a stumbling block we are perpetually clawing our way over, and why we're forced to replay every wave of every modern civil rights movement back from square one as the rest of society clucks its tongue whenever it's not in need of a scapegoat.

Alt-text: "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ChX4C56kITc"

The money trail is where the entire concept of "independent" game design comes from, and its importance as a production ethic freed from the baggage it comes with about content. It involves operating at a smaller scale and trying to mitigate at least some of that participation bias. Phone Story used its medium and design ethos to bolster its message about the horrible prices others pay for our luxuries: four mini-games in a looped "Obsolescence Mode" with each cycle representing a new model of the phone you're probably playing the game on. Sure, the "indie game" scene in conjunction with "New Games Journalism" spits out its fair share of auteur worship and faux-academic navel-gazing. And yes, it's aggravating when dozens of relatively smart people fail to realize both "input without agency" and "Slavoj Zizek without self-awareness" are usually just Really Tedious. Even so, underneath all that preening and posturing, there is a far more valid claim at the populist spirit than the AAA system could or would ever offer.

There's nothing that confirms this way of analyzing the world than the framing we use to predict the future of the current studio system: worries over another "collapse". But just because Call of Duty has to start receding sometime doesn't mean anyone's can scry the coming of the next epoch from sales figures. Despite Gearbox's colossal efforts, the landscape is too diverse for Atari E.T.-level fiascoes to cripple the whole industry. For big-ticket developers, the talent pool changes every time a new crop of fresh-out-of-school undergraduates finish DigiPen or their local arts department curriculum  (Having a job market perpetually overfilled with talent makes unionizing seem kind of unrealistic, doesn't it?) You'll never erase the stains Pitchford and Kuchera and Kotaku have left on us all by wishing them away. The only threat to the status quo comes when you start working with models and ideas that would make them obsolete.